The Boyfriend by R.L. Stine

I really wanted to give this book 5 stars, but I couldn’t get past how frustratingly naive Sydney was made to be. Throughout the story, there were so many red flags and questionable moments that she just ignored, and it was infuriating. I kept wanting her to dig deeper, to ask the obvious questions, but instead, she let things slide in a way that felt completely unrealistic. It was hard to stay fully immersed in the story because I kept getting frustrated with her choices—or lack of them.

That being said, the twist completely blew me away. I never saw it coming. I had so many theories while reading, and every time I thought I’d cracked the mystery, the story took another unexpected turn. None of my guesses came close to the truth, which is a rare and exciting experience as a reader. The unpredictability and tension had me hooked, and I found myself racing to finish just to see how it would all play out.

Overall, while Sydney’s characterization made it hard to fully enjoy the book, the clever plotting and shocking twists more than made up for it. If you love stories that keep you guessing and constantly surprise you, this one is absolutely worth picking up. I just wish the main character’s actions had been more believable, as that would’ve pushed this to a solid 5-star read for me.

This is the best one yet! I was not ready for the twist! A real page-turner that I was desperate to find out who the baddie was! Great!

I started with Never lie from the author and went on to the next , the boyfriend. It was an amazing book for any one who enjoys a twist even at the last minute, even when you think you have figured it all out, it comes when you least expect it. But the book grounds us in a reality from how different characters react finally according to my pov. Perhaps an optimistic reader would have expected ‘the boyfriend’ to finally find happiness, I mean he does in his own way, I think, but this is also why I think the book ground us in a reality that says there are some things in life, some bonds for better or worst we can’t easily get rid of and we all are not capable of overcoming it. Some of us just dive more into the depths.

This story starts with Sydney going on what could be called the worst first date of all time. The guy she met on a popular dating app looks nothing like his profile photo, he makes her split the bill, pressures her to drink, and then answers a call from his mother on their date. And then he’s aggressive when Sydney doesn’t want to kiss him, or go on another date.

But a mystery man comes to her rescue but then disappears back off into the night. Until weeks later, she’s on another date and runs into her mystery man again. Things take a different turn and they start dating. Until certain pink flags start popping up…

So Sydney’s character drove me a little crazy. She’s 34 years old and it seems like her whole life revolves around dating. Yes, that could be how the story is written and we just don’t learn more about her. But I think the other thing that drove me nuts about Sydney is that I know Sydney’s in real life, and I immediately thought of these people and how much their behavior drives me nuts. Just the sort of laser focus on dating and weddings and having kids and it’s like everything else barely exists. *As a caveat, you should do exactly what you want in life, but sometimes I feel like people sort of miss the forest for the trees when they do this*.

Tom is the other POV we see in this story and we’re seeing his past: from his first love, Daisy, to his father’s death, to the mysterious happenings in his hometown.

I know Freida McFadden is known for her big twists and I’d say this one was done quite well. I had suspected it to some extent just because some things were too obvious; kind of like in CSI when they aggressively interview the first person 10 minutes in; you know it CAN’T be them since there’s another 40 minutes of the show left.

I would definitely recommend this story if you’re looking for a popcorn thriller that’s an easy read, and fast paced. There isn’t a massive amount of character development, but the story moves quickly and this one is a quick read that will leave you wondering what the hell just happened.

The Boyfriend—now this is a book packed with surprises! What starts as a light, slow-burnish rom-com quickly takes a dark, bloody turn. Sydney Shaw, like many single women in New York, is no stranger to dating disasters—she’s met men who lie on their profiles, men who disappear when the bill arrives, and even the type who can’t stop talking about their mothers. But finally, she’s hit the jackpot with her new boyfriend, a charming, handsome doctor. Sydney is completely swept off her feet.

Then, the brutal murder of a young woman—the latest in a string of coastal killings—shocks the city. A mysterious man, known for dating women only to murder them, is the prime suspect. Sydney should feel safe with her dream boyfriend, yet suspicions begin to grow. What if he’s not as perfect as he seems? As blood-soaked revelations keep coming, tension escalates, and Sydney realizes someone may be watching her every move. 👀 She must uncover the truth before it’s too late—or she might be the killer’s next victim. The suspense builds until an absolutely jaw-dropping ending that left me stunned!

This book is pretty much perfect for spooky season—spooky, bloody, and guaranteed to keep you on the edge of your seat!